Zero Knowledge · Read

Chapter 36

The Forty-First

[secp-closed] Dormant output spent — 1Nq4vT7hR2mKfXpS9uWbYcG3dLzA5jQeVn Anders Roeg · 04:12 UTC

Posting this here because it’ll be on the aggregators within the hour and they’ll get it wrong.

The address above holds 3,911.4 BTC. It was spent from exactly once, in March 2015, so the public key has been sitting in the clear on every full node on earth for fifteen years.

At 03:58 UTC the whole balance moved in one transaction. The fee was sixty times the going rate for that block.

I am not making a claim about who signed it. But it moved.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Wu Jiaming · 04:31 UTC

I am not making a claim about who signed it.

That is the forty-first this week. Nineteen of the forty-one are in the last twenty-six hours.

Four people have asked me today whether these are owners or thefts. I have no idea. The same transaction can be generated by a frightened owner and a recovered key.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Grace Oyelaran · 04:47 UTC

Anders, look at where it went.

The destination is P2TR. The x-only public key is written into the output script. So somebody moved 3,911 coins out of a fifteen-year-old exposed address and into a brand new exposed address. Whoever it is thinks that helped.

These people are idiots. They should be moving things to a fresh hash-locked output.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Petra Halloran · 05:02 UTC

I put a patch on the list at 02:00. Three hours, nobody. So I am putting it here also since you people seem to care.

It is a consensus rule. Any output whose public key was visible on chain before block 1,108,000 becomes unspendable. It is roughly 4.1 million coins. Satoshi’s are in it. My own 2013 change addresses are in it.

This removes the target. I have not seen another proposal that does this.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Dmitri Sarkis · 05:09 UTC

Petra, your proposed patch takes four million coins from people who have not done anything, and you picked the block height yourself. That’s not a useful patch.

A large number of the addresses on your list belong to people who are dead. You are proposing to confiscate from the dead as a safety measure.

And the ones who are alive have to be told they can hold it and they can never move it. That’s not going to fly.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Petra Halloran · 05:14 UTC

My brother’s twelve coins are in it, from when I set his wallet up in 2013 and told him it was better than a savings account. I told him what was happening on Sunday. He said okay, and then he called me back an hour later and asked if I was going to be all right.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Wu Jiaming · 05:26 UTC

The patch does not have a BIP number.

I do not want my name on the paperwork.

Ask me again on Friday. Maybe I’ll change my mind.

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Anders Roeg · 05:44 UTC

Off topic, and I’d like to know if it happened to anyone else here.

I had a call at 01:40 my time from people who wouldn’t say who they work for. I don’t think they were a state. They knew which lists I read, including this closed one, which is nine people.

They offered to pay for the coordination of an emergency root rotation, at scale, starting now. Then they asked me which people on this list I would trust with a key.

I haven’t answered them.

Somebody on this list either talked to them or is one of them. Which one of you did this?

Re: [secp-closed] Dormant output spent Dmitri Sarkis · 06:31 UTC

I moved mine at 06:15. All of it.

I’ve spent eleven years telling people not to panic-move coins and I did it in four minutes on a phone, in my kitchen, while I was standing up. My wife laughed at me and told me to do something useful and make her a sandwich.


TESSERA — SUPPORT — LIVE CHAT Session 8815-4402 · opened 13:22 UTC

You are number 1,184 in the queue. Estimated wait time: 6 hours 40 minutes. Please do not close this window.

You are now connected to Ruth L.

Ruth L. · 19:58 UTC Hi, thanks for your patience today. How can I help?

Customer · 19:58 UTC I want to withdraw my money.

Ruth L. · 19:59 UTC I understand. All customer funds are safe and fully accounted for. Withdrawals are temporarily paused while we complete our review. We appreciate your patience and we will update all customers by email as soon as we have news.

Customer · 20:00 UTC I don’t have bitcoin. I sold in November. There is thirty-eight thousand dollars in that account. I am closing on a house on the ninth. I need the cash.

Ruth L. · 20:01 UTC I’m very sorry. Cash balances are included in the pause.

Customer · 20:01 UTC Since when.

Customer · 20:02 UTC Do you have my money.

Ruth L. · 20:03 UTC All customer funds are safe and fully accounted for.

Customer · 20:03 UTC That doesn’t make me feel any better. How do I get my money.

Ruth L. · 20:06 UTC I can escalate this to our funds team and someone will contact you within five business days.

Customer · 20:07 UTC It just went up on your website. Trading is halted. That was not there twenty minutes ago.

Ruth L. · 20:08 UTC Yes.

Customer · 20:08 UTC Did you know that was coming.

Ruth L. · 20:11 UTC No.

Customer · 20:12 UTC What did you do with yours.

Ruth L. · 20:14 UTC I moved mine on Tuesday.

Customer · 20:14 UTC Tuesday.

Ruth L. · 20:15 UTC I shouldn’t have said that. I’m going to have to transfer you.

Ruth L. has left the conversation.

You are number 1,209 in the queue. Estimated wait time: 7 hours 5 minutes. Please do not close this window.


“What Is Bitcoin? Explained In Plain English” · Ridgeline Money · 17 years ago 341,882 views · 39,415 of them today · newest first

PINNED · oakhurst_dan · 16 years ago · 3.2K likes Best explanation on here by a mile. Sending this to my brother in law who thinks it’s a scam.

wendell.p · 3 minutes ago why is everyone here

takoma_88 · 4 minutes ago the news said the math is broken. what math. i have money in this

jsantiago4141 · 5 minutes ago Your bank is fine. Banks use 256 bit which is a completely different thing. · 1.1K likes

halverson_r · 5 minutes ago That’s not what that number means. It’s not the same math and it’s not — you know what, never mind. · 2 likes

bonnie_mcw · 7 minutes ago is this why my card wouldn’t go through at the pharmacy this morning?

pete_from_ohio · 7 minutes ago that’s not related

bonnie_mcw · 8 minutes ago how do you know

gutterball99 · 9 minutes ago My nephew tried to explain this to me at Easter. I didn’t understand any of it. I just watched the video. I still don’t understand it. · 8.4K likes

dvorak_enjoyer · 11 minutes ago whatever happened with the two people in colorado they were looking for · 1 like

marisleaf · 12 minutes ago this video is wrong now. leaving it up is going to hurt somebody. take it down

Ridgeline Money · 14 minutes ago Comments on this video will be limited shortly. We cannot answer questions about your individual accounts.

kenny_two_stroke · 16 minutes ago Took it all out of the credit union this morning. Nineteen thousand and change. The teller had to get the manager. It’s in a coffee can on top of my refrigerator.

Free to read · all rights reserved · © 2026 Brad Feld and Phin Argofy

the newsletter

Get the next chapter by email.

Zero Knowledge is being written in the open. New chapters go straight to your inbox the day they post — you'll be first to read what happens next. Unsubscribe anytime.